# Reply to Shopify Return Requests Using Your Own Policy

> Researched. Small business · Beginner · Inbox. Updated 2026-11-08.

Canonical page: https://www.aisetupsthatwork.com/setups/reply-to-shopify-return-requests/

## What it does
A clear approve or decline draft for each return request, checked against your own written policy.

## Who it's for
Shopify sellers with self-serve returns who spend too long writing the same return replies.

## Tools
- Shopify self-serve returns (Orders, Return requested)
- Your returns policy text
- ChatGPT or Claude

## Steps
1. Open the order showing "Return requested" in Shopify.
2. Copy the reason, order date and item, and your returns policy.
3. Paste them into the prompt below.
4. Decide yourself, then approve or decline in Shopify with the message.

## Copy-paste prompt
Adapt bracketed fields to your situation.
```text
Check this return request against my policy and draft my reply. Do not approve, decline or refund anything.

My returns policy: [paste]
Order date and delivery date: [dates]
Item and condition described: [paste]
Customer's reason: [paste]

1. Does it fit the policy? Quote the line that decides it. If it is unclear, say so.
2. Draft an approve message (with next steps) and a decline message (kind, with the policy line), each under 80 words.
3. An internal note for my records.
```

## Guardrails
- What it touches: Chat input you provide (Shopify self-serve returns (Orders, Return requested); Your returns policy text).
- Needs your OK: Send, pay, publish, delete, and CRM updates stay with you unless you explicitly opt in.
- Safety level: Drafts for you
- You make the call: Use the draft as a check, not a decision. Edge cases, damaged items and repeat returners need your judgment.
- No written policy. Write one first with the returns policy setup.
- It sounds stiff. Ask it to match your store voice.

## Tips
- Keep your policy short and specific so the check is easy.
- Save your best replies as Shopify templates.

## Estimates (labeled, not measured)
- Time saved: not measured yet
- Money saved: Not stated in sources.
- Tool cost: Self-serve returns are part of Shopify. ChatGPT and Claude have free plans with usage limits.

## Sources
Summaries use the public sources below, not independent verification.
- Shopify Help Center: https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/fulfillment/managing-orders/returns/self-serve-returns/management (Checked through search results Nov 8, 2026 (the build machine was blocked from opening it): self-serve return requests show a "Return requested" card on the order, and you approve or decline with an internal reason and a message to the customer.)

## Get the free starter pack
Five beginner copy-paste AI setups, free by email: https://www.aisetupsthatwork.com/starter-pack/?utm_source=ai-agent&utm_medium=markdown&utm_campaign=setup-reply-to-shopify-return-requests

Related:
- [Write a clear ecommerce returns policy page](https://www.aisetupsthatwork.com/setups/write-an-ecommerce-returns-policy/index.md)
- [Answer order status emails with AI](https://www.aisetupsthatwork.com/setups/answer-order-status-emails-with-ai/index.md)
